As already stated in my previous post, I'm very excited about this book. Dan Lepard's renowned book The Handmade Loaf, together with his excellent baking forum and weekly baking column in the Guardian have established him as one of the best bakers in the UK. I ordered the book back in April and had to wait six long months before it finally arrived through my letterbox.
First off, this is a nice hefty book with over 550 pages and a distinctive tricolour cover. It's bound in such a way that the page stays open at pretty much any point, most unusual and very welcome.
In true Dan Lepard style, the recipes are inspirational. I leapt straight to the chapter on cakes of course, but the book starts with the real staff of life - bread. Other sections include biscuits, desserts, savoury pies, yeasted sweet bakes and even a chapter on making your own sweets. Each chapter starts with a few pages of techniques; tips are scattered throughout the book. On reading the tips and techniques section of the cake chapter, I noted several things I was unaware of. I'm an inveterate forgetter of remembering to turn the oven on in time. I was particularly pleased therefore to discover that it doesn't matter too much if you don't place the finished cake mixture immediately in the oven. If you transfer it very gently, the "rise" should not be affected.
Dan uses some unusual ingredients in his cake recipes including rye and hemp flours, ground porridge oats and condensed milk. That and some unusual techniques make for an intriguing baking experience. Apart from the chocolate ones (of course), some of the cakes I'm looking forward to making include: cherry beet cake, sticky lemon & poppy seed cake, coconut milk layer cake and saffron peach cake.
Although I like to think of myself as a serious cook, I do find I like to have photographs in my cookbooks. It's always nice to have an idea of what your aiming for and sometimes it's the picture alone that seals the deal on whether you bake a particular recipe. This was my one disappointment with Short & Sweet, there are photographs and very enticing ones too, but they don't cover every bake. A book mark ribbon would also be a welcome addition, but I guess I can live without that.
You can watch a 50 second video of Dan talking about his book here.
As regular readers will know I always give my own views on any items I review. In this case I bought the book for myself so you can be doubly sure that I do indeed think it's a classic and will make an excellent addition to any baking library.
So, to the giveaway and your chance to win one of the three copies. You must leave a comment on this post answering the question below. You have until midnight on Friday 21st October when the giveaway closes. The winners will be randomly selected after this date. Apologies to oversees visitors, but this is only open to those with a UK or Ireland postal address.
What cake recipe do you consider to be indispensable in a cookbook?
Additional entries can also be made by (but you must answer the question above for these to be eligible):
- Following my blog via Google Friend Connect - leave a separate comment here telling me you have done so.
- Following me on Twitter - leave a separate comment here telling me you have done so with your Twitter id.
- Tweeting this message "win a copy of @dan_lepard Short & Sweet from Chocolate Log Blog @Choclette8 - bit.ly/pE6ARV" - leave a separate comment here telling me you have done so
- Liking this post on Facebook - leave a separate comment here telling me you have done so.
22 October Update. This giveaway is now closed. The three winners have been drawn using Random.Org as follows:
- 78 - Nursey
- 53 - Janice
- 37 - Dom






Have followed you with GFC (thought I already was, but apparently not) - Grapevine
ReplyDeleteHave followed you on Twitter @janesgrapevine
ReplyDeleteHave tweeted @janesgrapevine
ReplyDeletetweeted @bospherous
ReplyDeleteLiked your FB page.
ReplyDeleteAlready following your blog.
ReplyDeleteShared this announcement on twitter @simplyf00d
ReplyDeleteFollowing you on twitter@simplyf00d
ReplyDeleteThe cake that should be a staple in every cook book has to be the good old chcolate cake, I adore it in any shape or form, with a twist, boozy, nutty, sticky or gooey! I am bias however, as like I said, I do like choclate. @stralisemiai
ReplyDeleteI have followed your fantastic blog through GFC, @stralisemiai
ReplyDeleteFollowing you on twitter @stralisemiai
ReplyDeleteI have also tweeted your fab giveaway and hope many others come to read your blog, I followed JanesGrapevine here after seeing her tweet on twitter.
ReplyDelete@stralisemiai
I clicked the link to 'like' your facebook post, but it lead to your information page, I was unsure which bit to like, so.. I shared the Dan Leopards link you had posted on your wall. I am Rach Lines on facebook. (A picture of a pink troll - you can search me looking for user - stralisemiai to confirm this step)
ReplyDeleteHope this is satisfactory, @Stralisemiai
This book looks and sounds amazing!! Every cookbook should have a fabulous chocolate cake recipe - my absol fav!!! :)
ReplyDeleteHave followed via GFC as Nicola (@NicsNotebook) I was already following via RSS feed! x
ReplyDeleteAm already following you on Twitter (@NicsNotebook) x
ReplyDeleteHave just tweeted your link as well x
ReplyDeleteHave added you as a friend on Facebook (Nicola McCandless) and once you accept, I will like your post :) x
ReplyDeleteNo book is complete without a classic Victoria sponge - so many other more advanced cakes are based on the technique. And a slight twist on the recipe or a change inpresentation can make it unique to the book.
ReplyDeleteI think it has to be a very good and very easy chocolate cake. Would you expect a different response?
ReplyDeleteFollowed you on twitter @kibibidesigns, Google friend - Teresa murphy, request sent on facebook and your link has been posted on twitter. Every good cook book needs a fabulous chocolate cake recipe, the one your kids will love and people will ask you for, that gets used at birthdays, parties, and picnics and you never tire of. Teresa xx
ReplyDeleteIt would have to be friut cake for me :) @CHOCOAJ x
ReplyDeleteI have tweeted your tweet and i am following as @CHOCOAJ xx
ReplyDeleteFollowing on facebook as Amanda Letch xx
ReplyDeleteI mean Fruit cake lol !
ReplyDelete(My posts are not showing up so trying using Anonymous!)
ReplyDeleteThere should be a robust sponge cake recipe because you can make so many variations.
@beachrambler
I am following via GFC - Hazel Rea
ReplyDelete@beachrambler
post liked on facebook - Teresa murphy, @kibibidesigns x
ReplyDeleteI am following on Twitter - @beachrambler
ReplyDeleteI have tweeted - @beachrambler
ReplyDeleteCake recipe simply a must in any book has to be devils chocolate cake that is full of chocolate.
ReplyDeleteI tried to think of something different from the cake most mentioned in the previous comments but as Chocolate Cake was my first thought it seems pointless thinking of something else. So there you have it - a very good chocolate cake is indispensable.
ReplyDeleteI follow you on Google Friend Connect.
ReplyDeleteObviously a good chocolate cake :) I would love to win one of these!!
ReplyDeleteI WANT THIS BOOK!!!... I think a perfect chocolate ake is what's needed in a good cookbook
ReplyDeleteI follow you on twitter and blog
ReplyDeleteI have tweeted your message x
ReplyDeleteI have liked your facebook post x
ReplyDeletei think three are indispensible: basic sponge, basic chocolate and basic fruit from which many varieties can be created.
ReplyDeleteI also follow your blog and follow you on twitter.
ReplyDeleteMany of the nice cakes Dan comes up with in The Guardian would qualify, of course. However, I think everyone needs one good foolproof recipe for a chocolate cake: a type which isn't fussy, doesn't require anything fancy and always works, that can be "dressed up" with a bit of cream or ice-cream or some nice frosting perhaps. But if we keep those who don't like chocolate in mind (not too many, surely), then a good "everyday cake" is a must: a nice, moist, not-too-sweet, goes-with-everything type of cake, with everyday ingredients, perhaps with some fruit, that can be whipped up quickly when the afternoon urge strikes (or friends visit unexpectedly).
ReplyDeleteJust tweeted your giveaway @queenocuts - hope I'm lucky
ReplyDeleteOhh how exciting! This is a hard question. I think after much thought I'd say it wasn't necessarily one type of cake recipe, but rather a cake recipe that the author/chef considers to be their signiture cake. The one they are most proud of or famous for. Everyone likes to be able to reporoduce a masterpiece :)
ReplyDeleteI already follow you on twitter
ReplyDeleteI like to see a plain 'maderia' type cake in a cookbook with a list of useful adaptations that themselves can be further adapted. Basic recipes encourage imagination as does a lack of pictures: because you don't have any idea of what they should look like ther can be no comparison or sense of failure, good for the confidence. Encourages everyone to have a go!
chocolate fudge cake
ReplyDelete@ashlallan
i follow with gfc as mummy24
ReplyDelete@ashlallan
i follow on twitter as @ashlallan
ReplyDeletei have tweeted as @ashlallan
ReplyDeleteWell my only way to enter is through leaving a comment so I'll give it a go anyhoo. Of course I am going to say the most important cake recipe in any book has to be a chocolate cake, preferably one that can be added to for the personal touch ... I rather think Nigella is great at those kind of recipes but I know that kind of goes against the purpose of your post here teehee
ReplyDeleteThe most important cake recipe for me is Nigella's Chocolate Guiness Cake, it has never failed and is a big hit with men and boys! Oh dear that doesn't sound right, I mean my husband and sons, of course!
ReplyDeleteI'm already following you on Google Reader.
ReplyDeleteI follow you on Twitter
ReplyDeleteI've tweeted your giveaway.
ReplyDeleteTried to like your post on FB but no joy, so sent you a Friend request instead!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the giveaway.
Why a good chocolate cake of course Choclette :)
ReplyDelete.... and I have all his unusual ingredients :)
I follow you on Google connect. Oh, I just noticed the whoopie pies, yum! Must go have a look after I do this.
ReplyDeleteSponge cake for sure. And chocolate cake. Do brownies count? Cuz that should be there too.
ReplyDeleteI follow you on twitter :)
ReplyDeleteHave tweeted from @monicashaw
ReplyDeleteI tweeted your message :)
ReplyDeleteI REALLY want this book!
ReplyDeleteMy cake would be a classic, light, airy and fluffy Victoria Sandwich.......
I already follow on twitter as @KarenBurnsBooth
ReplyDeleteI have tweeted:
ReplyDelete"win a copy of @dan_lepard Short & Sweet from Chocolate Log Blog @Choclette8 - bit.ly/pE6ARV"
@KarenBurnsBooth
Whoops, didn't realise my hubby was signed into facebook, so I have now requested a friendship through him. Re-did it for myself. Try not to report him. He is Graham snd not to blame, hehe. Oh and like button wasn't working so I shared your story on facebook instead, which I figured is even better :)
ReplyDeleteI have sent a friends request on FB as soon as you accept I will Like!
ReplyDeleteI think a nice fruit cake with brandy. @walpolegirl
ReplyDeleteI already follow you on twitter @walpolegirl
ReplyDeleteI have tweeted the message
ReplyDelete"win a copy of @dan_lepard Short & Sweet from Chocolate Log Blog @Choclette8 - bit.ly/pE6ARV" @walpolegirl
I have sent friend request on faqcebook.
ReplyDeletefollowing your blog
ReplyDeletefollowing you on twitter (you can tell i really, really, really want this! :)
ReplyDeletejust tweeted your message
ReplyDeleteAs I'm in full Christmas baking mode, a classic fruit cake is the most essential cake recipe!
ReplyDeleteI already follow you, but don't have facebook or twitter.
Great competion!
I'm in retro mode at the moment, so am judging all cook books on the quality of their lemon drizzle cakes - got to be soft, not too sweet and with just the right amount of lemon!
ReplyDeleteam following via GFC
ReplyDeletefollowing on twitter as @maxineflossy
ReplyDeletehave tweeted @maxineflossy
ReplyDeletehave shared your post on f/b!
ReplyDeleteI have liked your post on Facebook. =D
ReplyDeleteI've got a copy on its way to me from Amazon, but how nice that they gave you copies of Dan's book to give away, Choc! :)
ReplyDeleteYou are right - I do already follow your blog ;0)
ReplyDeleteAnd I do already follow you on facebook too!
ReplyDeleteFor me, it would have to be a really good fruit cake. I'm still using a recipe I scribbled down from the TV some 20 years ago :)
ReplyDelete@happyfox
Following on Twitter
ReplyDelete@happyfox
Tweeted @happyfox
ReplyDeleteFollowing with GFC
ReplyDeleteI think it really is essential to have an ultimate chocolate cake in any cookbook - it's an absolute must for me! Love Dan Lepard's recipes so really hope I win a copy! :)
ReplyDeleteFollowing you on twitter (@FoodieEmma)
ReplyDeleteTweeted the competition link! (@FoodieEmma)
ReplyDeletefollowing your blog already!
ReplyDeletefollowing on twitter too
ReplyDeletehave posted to my facebook profile!
ReplyDeletehave tweeted the message !!
ReplyDeleteNow for the fun bit - which cake recipe is indispensible???
ReplyDeletea really good chocolate cake - non floury, intensely chocolatey, melt in the mouth. My best one so far is chocolate nemesis from River Cafe cookbook x
Christmas cake!
ReplyDeleteAnd of course I follow you on twitter as well.
ReplyDeleteA classic pound cake!
ReplyDeleteam short on time so that is fine that I can't enter the comp but I am excited to hear about this book - am a dan fan myself - hope you are enjoying chocolate week - will read that post when I have more time
ReplyDeleteA nice simple, rich but decadent chocolate cake recipe is always indispensable to me.
ReplyDeleteFollowing on twitter. Twitter name is totally_forked!
ReplyDeleteMy first thought was a chocolate cake, but as everyone has said that, I will say the next one that popped in to my head and that's an easy peasy lemon squeezy lemon drizzle cake! Fruity and delicious my absolute go to cake, every cookery book should have a recipe for this! :)
ReplyDeleteI follow you on twitter @grazingkate
ReplyDelete...and I've tweeted the competition...
ReplyDelete...and I follow you on googleconnect or whatever it's called. Thank you for your comment on my birthday photo!
ReplyDeletePS what kind of word is 'mucation' to have as the security word verification!!??
What a great review (and look at all of these comments!).
ReplyDeleteI haven't read anything from Dan Lepard, yet. I'm still stuck somewhere between Elizabeth David and my Cordon Bleu books.
I don't like to see a staple thing in any cookbooks - I look for originality and new ideas rather than re-hashing old recipes again and again (unless they have something radically different to say about them).
I'm always intrigued to see a fruit cake recipe in cookbooks, just to see how different baker's interpret this classic! Lovely giveaway, and so pleased you like the book- I'm a huge fan of Dan's too!
ReplyDelete... and I follow your blog!...
ReplyDelete...and follow you on twitter...
ReplyDelete...and will retweet now!...
ReplyDeleteIt has to be a good basic Victoria Sponge, although a delicious chocolate cake is also pretty indispensible!
ReplyDeleteA good fruit cake recipe is essential, well thats my opinion!
ReplyDelete@daisyangel1
I'm following on GFC
ReplyDelete@daisyangel1
I'm following you on twitter too
ReplyDelete@daisyangel1
I have tweeted too
ReplyDelete@daisyangel1
We also follow you on Twitter as @astroracoffee and have retweeted the competition reminder.
ReplyDeleteHave tweeted the competition reminder!
ReplyDeleteopps I've tweeted the competition reminder twitter name totally_forked.
ReplyDeleteHmmm... for me at my current stage in life it would be a failsafe birthday cake, one that will become your family birthday cake, able to be adapted but reliable and a bit special. @mitchdafish
ReplyDeleteA must in every cook book? Definitely chocolate cake, of course! The book just won't be complete without it.
ReplyDeleteOh, in case you're wondering, I have a UK mailing address too (in case I win...crossing my fingers!).
I followed you on Twitter as @Divababu.
ReplyDeleteI also tweeted about this giveaway!
ReplyDeleteI follow you on twitter. I'm @gillbla
ReplyDeleteI just tweeted as well
ReplyDeleteI've followed you on google connect
ReplyDelete